We’re championing imagination, unpromptedTwo years on, our research has a new critical element at its heart: craft.

Author
Ellie Hennessey, Strategist and Insights Lead
Date
Category
AI
Reading time
5 minutes

Two years ago, we set out to prove something we’d long believed: imagination isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s a measurable driver of business performance. Imagination makes work interesting – and it makes the best brands stand out.

A lot has changed in two years, so we’ve revisited our research and identified a new critical element: craft.

For our 2024 report, The Business of Imagination, we surveyed 500 senior B2B decision-makers. Among the most imaginative companies, 58% had grown revenue considerably and 76% described themselves as very resilient. Among the least imaginative, 92% had seen their revenue shrink.

We identified four behaviours that set imaginative businesses apart. They collaborate across functions; look ahead and fail fast; let ideas come from anywhere; and invest real time, budget and attention in creativity.

What’s changed

Back in 2024, we described AI as a useful but limited tool. We said it was bound to past data and couldn’t produce anything new, so our advice was to double down on human ingenuity.

That no longer holds, necessarily. AI is now part of everyday creative and strategic work, and it’s getting harder to tell human creativity apart from machine-assisted work. So we went back to our argument and added new research.

The first finding overturned our old assumption. Across four studies, AI boosted individual creativity and helped people come up with more novel and useful ideas. The catch comes when creativity happens at scale.

We’ve all seen it: when everyone uses the same tools, ideas drift towards the same “good enough” narratives, taglines, illustration styles, visual treatments and more. Because you get out what you put in: a varied set of ideas is far more likely to include one rare, original gem that leads to a real breakthrough.

Imagination matters more than ever today not because AI can’t create, but because it makes everyone create alike. That backs up a claim we made in our original report: imagination belongs to the organisation as a whole, not to one talented person.

Prompting with intent

The answer isn’t to avoid AI. It’s to use it purposefully. Research suggests that structured, deliberate use of AI can strengthen critical thinking.

Professor Michael Gerlich of the Swiss Business School ran a study where some people used ChatGPT with structured prompts designed to improve their thinking. Expert reviewers scored their essays higher than essays written with unguided AI or with no AI at all. His advice? Think the problem through yourself first, then ask AI for feedback.

Practice matters, too. Research co-authored by Yeun Joon Kim of Cambridge Judge Business School found that people get better at creating with AI over time, if they have the right guidance. He points to Netflix, which splits script development into stages, with people and AI doing different amounts of each.

Introducing craft

So how do people keep their edge? The research points to two places.

The first is origination. When people lead the early thinking, organisations keep the variety of ideas that AI would otherwise flatten.

The second is judgement. KPMG found that only about half of people actually improve on what AI produces alone: adding value on top of AI is a skill, and it’s getting harder.

Essentially, it comes down to craft: the taste, discernment and discipline to know when to use AI and when to shut it down. This isn’t a rejection of technology; it’s a demonstration of the uniquely human choices people make and the wild-card ideas they bring to the blank page that the tools never can.

It became clear to us that this is the fifth behaviour of an imaginative business.

Why craft pays

There’s a parallel in art history. Once, rich patrons paid for the paint itself: ultramarine could cost more than gold. Over time they started paying for the artist’s skill instead, and when ultramarine was made synthetically in the 1820s, the colour lost its premium. AI is doing the same thing to creative execution, so the value clients now pay for is human taste and judgement.

Craft shapes how machines describe your brand as well as how people see it: 94% of B2B buyers use AI when making decisions, and AI tools are more likely to recommend brands with high-quality, original content.

It matters within businesses, too. Passive AI use has led to a 20% drop in people’s sense of ownership in their work, and a 10% drop in how meaningful they found it. That’s not just a risk to creative career satisfaction: Gallup links a highly engaged workforce to 23% higher profitability and 18% higher productivity.

Let’s craft

The challenge for business leaders has changed. It used to be how to go beyond data analysis to be more imaginative. Now it’s how to use AI to strengthen our imagination.

The answer is to pair AI’s speed with human origination, choice and judgement. And it means treating craft as a capability to invest in, measure and model from the top.

Does your business value craft? Look out for our full report and assessment, coming soon.

Related thinking

Three bright white fingerprints arranged vertically against a solid black background.

The Prompt: We are all responsible

Laura Taddei knows how to stay balanced – and sane – in an AI world.

Louise Sheeran, Content Director

A hand holding a black pen draws on a black and white checkerboard grid with numbers in some of the squares.

Creative differences

How AI problem-solving is changing the game (but not devaluing imagination)

Ben Bush, Partner and Head of Strategy

See all thinking ↗