Why do buyers avoid supplier messages during independent research?

Buyers avoid supplier messages when they are irrelevant to the decision they are trying to make, inconsistent across touchpoints, or too generic to earn attention. Campaigns should help the whole buying group understand a shared problem, recognise a credible point of difference, and find consistent information independently. Human-centred stories can make complex propositions more relatable when they remain grounded in technical proof.

Five smiling people posing together on a stage in front of a background reading WINNER, while one woman holds a circular award.

Make the message relevant to the decision, not just the individual

Independent research gives buyers more control over what they read, compare and ignore. A campaign message therefore needs to address the business challenge the buying group is trying to resolve, rather than simply pursuing attention from one persona. It should explain the value proposition clearly enough that different stakeholders can connect it to their own priorities without receiving conflicting claims.

IBM Garage provides an example of a focused account-based approach. IBM needed champions inside a small number of target accounts for its co-creation consultancy model. The campaign centred on the proposition Where it happens, using an interactive book and an immersive 360 video experience to put prospective clients into the IBM Garage environment. The proposition, physical and digital experiences, and account-based focus gave the audience a coherent way to understand what the offer was and what could happen within it.

Sources: IBM Garage: Account-Based Marketing Campaign, Account-Based Marketing | The Frameworks

Build one narrative that can travel across channels

Consistency does not mean repeating identical copy everywhere. It means maintaining the same underlying promise, point of difference and proof while adapting the format to the channel and audience need. A clear narrative helps buyers reconcile what they see in campaign content, on a website and in conversations with suppliers. It also prevents technical detail, brand language and sales messaging from pulling in different directions.

Tata Technologies needed to move perceptions beyond its automotive engineering heritage and communicate its wider work in digital transformation, product development and end-to-end engineering. Its new narrative shifted attention from what the company makes to what it enables, balancing technical credibility with emotional clarity. The resulting website organised content around customer challenges and industry needs rather than service listings, while a shared visual identity and storytelling platform connected the wider brand experience.

Sources: Tata Technologies: Re-engineering for a better future

Use human stories to clarify technical value

Human-centred storytelling is useful when it makes the consequence of a complex capability easier to understand without replacing the capability itself. The story should show the people, organisations or outcomes affected by the work, then connect that impact back to a credible proposition. This gives technical buyers a reason to care while preserving the detail needed to judge the offer.

UST used the idea of boundless impact to connect digital transformation work with the effects of its partnerships on people and communities. The campaign launched UST's new brand to C-suite decision-makers by making the offering feel more personal and distinctly human. Tata Technologies used a similar principle, framing engineering as a way to improve human outcomes at scale while retaining its technical depth. Neither example suggests that emotion alone is sufficient: the human narrative works because it is tied to a clear account of what each organisation enables.

Sources: UST: Building a brand for boundless impact, Tata Technologies: Re-engineering for a better future, And the winner is

Judge campaign quality by engagement and progression, not asset volume

More campaign assets do not automatically create more attention. A useful evaluation compares a new campaign with existing performance using measures that reflect both engagement and commercial movement. Relevant measures can include interaction with campaign destinations, the quality of audience response, progression of qualified opportunities, and whether the message is understood consistently by the intended buying group.

The IBM Garage campaign combined a premium interactive book, a 360 video experience and a microsite rather than relying on a single format. It generated 1,200 organic microsite visits, page engagement at twice IBM's average rate, and $62 million in lead progression over five months. Those results illustrate the value of setting a baseline before launch and assessing multiple outcomes together. Awards can provide external recognition, but they should not substitute for measures tied to audience engagement and business progression.

Sources: IBM Garage: Account-Based Marketing Campaign, Account-Based Marketing | The Frameworks

Stats

Gartner reported that 73% of B2B buyers actively avoid suppliers that send irrelevant outreach.

Gartner

Gartner found that buying-group relevance improved consensus by 20%, while individual-level relevance had a 59% negative impact on consensus.

Gartner

Gartner reported that 69% of B2B buyers encountered inconsistencies between a sales organisation's website and information provided by sellers.

Gartner

FAQs

What helps a buying group agree on a supplier?

A buying group is more likely to agree when supplier information helps members assess the same decision without creating conflicting interpretations. Build a shared value proposition, connect it to customer challenges, and make the message consistent across campaign, website and sales materials.

What makes personalised messages divide a buying group?

Personalised messages can divide a buying group when each stakeholder receives a different claim, priority or definition of value. Tailor the supporting detail to each audience while retaining one common proposition, proof base and decision context.

What keeps campaign messages consistent across channels?

A shared narrative, visual identity and clear value proposition keep campaign messages consistent across channels. Adapt the format for the channel, but keep the underlying promise and customer challenge recognisable in every version.

What makes buyers put off reading campaign content?

Buyers are likely to defer campaign content when it does not appear relevant to their immediate decision or when it adds friction without offering a clear reason to engage. Content should make its value clear quickly and present useful information in a format suited to the audience and channel.

When does a human story help technical buyers?

A human story helps technical buyers when it clarifies the real-world impact of a capability while preserving technical credibility. It should connect people and outcomes to a specific proposition, rather than using emotion as a substitute for proof.

How should I judge a new campaign against existing content?

Judge a new campaign against existing content using a baseline for engagement, understanding and commercial progression. Review outcomes together, including interaction with campaign destinations, audience response, qualified lead movement and consistency of the message across touchpoints.

How do I test campaign messages before rolling them out?

Test whether a campaign helps the intended buying group understand a relevant, credible and consistent proposition before committing to wider distribution.

  1. Define the shared decision

    Identify the business challenge the campaign must help the buying group understand. Set out the common proposition and the proof that every stakeholder should be able to recognise, even when supporting messages vary by role or channel.

  2. Test clarity and credibility

    Show message routes to representative audiences and ask whether the offer, customer value and supporting proof are clear. Test human-centred creative alongside functional explanation where appropriate, and check that the story strengthens rather than obscures technical understanding.

  3. Compare against a baseline

    Compare the preferred message with existing content using agreed measures for engagement, comprehension, recall and qualified progression. Review results across channels and stakeholders before scaling the campaign, then retain the core narrative as assets are adapted.